Pedometers are becoming
increasingly popular in assessing physical fitness due to its economic value
and its high correlation with physical activity levels. To date, there are no
studies exploring the accuracy of different types of pedometers when measuring
different locomotor movements. Therefore the purpose of this study was to
determine the accuracy of the two pedometers when walking, skipping, galloping,
sliding, and hopping. Sixty-two male and female college students (23.4±4.6
yrs, 68.7±4.4 inches, 167.8±36.6 lbs) were fitted with a spring-loaded (SL)
pedometer (Yamax, LS 7010, Japan) and a piezoelectric (PE) pedometer (New
Lifestyles NL-800, MO, USA) side by side on the right anterior hip, then
performed the randomly assigned movements for the length (85.5 ft) of a
hardwood court playing surface, during which time the investigator tallied the
steps with a hand counter (Lab Safety Supply Inc, Model No. 77270, USA). Each
step with the lead foot elicited a tally on the counter. Participants were
instructed to perform the movement at a brisk pace, to jump-stop at the end of
the court, and to remain still until after the pedometer reading was recorded.
Time was given, if needed, to recover before the next trial. Repeated measure
ANOVAs using the Bonferroni technique were used to compare differences between
pedometer counts and hand counts. See Table 1 for results. In
conclusion, the PE pedometer demonstrated better agreement versus the SL
pedometer when compared to the hand tally during each locomotor movement. Both
seem to miss some vertical forces produced by the trail leg during skipping,
galloping, and sliding movements. If using pedometers to accurately assess
these types of movements, the PE pedometer should be considered.
Table 1. Step Counts Measured Using the Pedometers and Hand
Tally
|
|
Hand Tally
|
Spring-Loaded
|
Piezoelectric
|
Walking
|
31.9±3.2
|
33.0±5.6
|
33.2±3.4*
|
Skipping
|
18.1±3.4
|
28.4±8.0*
|
23.1±5.3**
|
Galloping
|
17.9±2.9
|
27.5±8.2*
|
22.7±5.6**
|
Sliding
|
19.0±3.1
|
30.4±9.6*
|
23.5±6.6**
|
Hopping
|
24.8±6.2
|
26.8±7.2*
|
27.0±6.3*
|
Note: Values represent Mean ±
SD
*Significantly different from
hand tally, p < .01
** Significantly different
from hand tally and SL, p < .01
|